As you are probably aware, The Triangle estate has a number of covered garages situated at the ground level of the estate. These garages have not always been kept in the best repair. The garage area itself has historically been vandalised and, due to lack of security and inadequate lighting, has not been considered the safest area on the estate.
Despite this, many residents with cars have applied for spaces in the garages. Unfortunately not eveyone has been succesfull, and in recent discussions with HFI it was stated that there were up to thirteen residents on waiting list for a garage space, with some people having been on the list for quite some time (some time being measured in years!).
One the face of it, this seems unfortunate but could be purely the result of too few garages and too many residents with cars. However, it has been stated off-record by HFI that approximately twenty three garages are being held empty so that they can be used by contractors when the scheduled Major Works programme begins.
As anyone on the estate can attest to, their have been significant delays in Major Works program, specifically related to HFI’s inability to satisfy Islington Council’s South Area Planning Committee.
So to summarise the situation we currently have:
- 13 residents on a waiting list for garage spaces, some for a number of years.
- 23 available spaces have been left empty, earmarked for contractors involved in works that have not even been accepted by the Council Planning Committee. The original start date for the Major Works was in June, leading to the assumption that these garages must have been empty since at least then. We still, even now, do not have a start date for these works.
It appears that an adjustment of the prioritisation system used for the allocation of garages is needed. HFI seems to be penalising tenants at the cost of keeping garages empty for what is effectively their own use. From the figures above it is obvious that EVERY tennant that is waiting for a garage could have one immediately, whilst still providing a number of garages spare.
Common sense would dictate that an equitable prioritisation system would look something like:
- Residents with special needs
- Residents
- All others (with resident requirements superceding any rental agreement)
Under this scheme, all residents could be provided with a garage, and any spare spaces allocated to contractors as required. If all garages were allocated and another resident required a garage, at the end of the current rental period for a non-resident garage leasee, that garage would be re-allocated to the resident.
The next step in investigating this issue is to ask HFI to provide information on the number, state and rental status of each garage. Following this would be a request to implement a prioritisation scheme that puts more emphasis on the rights of the people who live at The Triangle. Stay tuned.